Thinking Biblically- John W. Robbins - The Trinity Review; Sep-Dec-2015
What Is Thinking?
The Definition of Thinking
1. To form or have in mind.
2. To intend or plan.
3. To have an opinion or to regard as.
4. To reflect on, to ponder. The list goes on
until definition nine which is,
9. To subject to the processes of logical
thought.
All of these words convey the general meaning to make judgments, to reason, to
subject to the processes of logical thought.
In fact the Bible describes animals as having souls. They are conscious, they are aware, but they do not think. Thinking involves understanding. The Scripture says in many verses that the animals do not understand, and that is a clue to what
the image of God is. Words tag thoughts. We use words to refer to ideas. Thinking involves words. It is impossible for us to think without words.
Who thinks?
Persons think. It is thinking that makes a person. God thinks. […] groups do not think either. Only persons think […]
Remember that in our working definition, thinking
was connecting one idea with another. Seeing connections between ideas and drawing inferences is involved in thinking.
There is nothing too great for words.
[…] logic is the way God thinks
[God has no need for logic], logic steers the universe and, in fact, it created the universe― John 1:1-3
[Logos does not mean Logic].
A word is an expression of thought, and it is thought that controls the universe, nothing else.
We do not learn about ourselves through introspection. We learn about ourselves
through Scripture.
If we want to know ourselves, we have to know Scripture.
Edwards also wrote, “It cannot be said that we come to the knowledge of any
part of Christian truth by the light of nature, it is only the Word of God contained in the Old and New Testament, which teaches us Christian divinity.
If this be Gnosticism, let us make the most of it.
Edwards says salvation comes through knowledge.
Faith is knowledge.
[Faith is not knowledge. All knowledge is acquired thru faith. Faith is
mental assent, knowledge is information. This is a serious error in Robbins’ epistemology.]
Question: Are babies capable of thinking?
Answer: Babies are not capable of thinking as we have defined it.
Question: Isn’t it true that Christianity is not a religion, but a relationship?
Answer: If you read the Bible, you will see that the command is always to believe the
Word. How am I to be saved? “Believe in the Lord Jesus Christ and you will be saved” (Acts 16:31) Judas had a personal relationship with Jesus Christ.
It did him no good,
Question: Does not Romans 1 say that we can discern the existence of God from the creation?
Answer: Romans 1 appears to say that, but it does not say that. Christ denies that
anyone knows God except through Him, so any construction of the philosophers that purports to prove the existence of God is a figment of their
imagination. The arguments that have been constructed to prove the existence of God should not be seen as aids to evangelism or the Christian religion, but as impediments.
Paul says in 1 Corinthians 1:21, “The world by
wisdom did not know God ….” Paul in the first four chapters of 1 Corinthians is intent on denying natural theology. In fact, he is intent on denying any source of knowledge except Scripture.
Jesus says in Matthew 11:27, “No one knows the
Father except the Son and he to whom the Son reveals him.”
If it is true that you are what you eat, it is also true to say that you are
what you know. The mind is nourished by the truth of being as the body is nourished by food. […] in all our knowing we are enlightened by the truth which is God […]
Rudolf Harvey; The Primacy of Truth; Franciscan Studies; v9; n3; 1949; p263
[…] Kierkegaard makes it clear that truth is a person ‒ Christ.
If
truth is to be taught, the teacher must provide the learner with the
condition for understanding the truth. The teacher must transform, not
reform, the learner. But this is impossible unless the teacher is the very
God who created the learner.
[…] Climacus
proceeds with the assumption that man is created by God and that when God
created him He must have given him the condition for understanding the
truth. […] at one point man, obviously through his own fault, fell
into untruth. […] Since man is now bound in this condition and unable
to work himself loose, he thus needs a saviour. The saviour is the one who
desires to teach man truth […]
Having ‘discovered’ that if truth is
to be learned it must must be given through certain acts of God, as we have
mentioned, and received with certain capacities that God likewise gives […]
Matthew G. Jacoby;
Kierkegaard on Truth; Religious Studies; v38; n1; 2002
If the Christian truth were simply a message Christ brought to us, then its
content would be essentially detachable from his person, and his coming to bring it would be of vanishing importance ― merely one way of conveying to
us a message that we would in principle be capable of grasping in his absence. But for the Christian, the truth is the person of Christ, so his
coming is of absolutely decisive significance.
Stephen Mulhall; Faith & Reason; 1994; p73
In Arminian theology… God can only make salvation
“possible”; He cannot
actually save individual men unless they want to be saved.
Cornelius van
Til; The Defense of the Faith; 1967; p5
There is indeed nothing more ridiculous than to imagine that any motion or
modification of matter should produce thought.
Thomas Reid; (1710-1796);
Essays on the Intellectual Powers of Man; 1764
Later in the same prayer, Jesus declares that God’s word is truth (John
17:17), but again, since Jesus himself is the present form of God’s word in
this narrative discourse, this also entails a declaration about himself.
Andrew T. Lincoln; Truth on Trial; 2000; p224
Q: What do you say to the atheists who demand evidence or proof of the
existence of a transcendent reality?
A: The hidden assumption behind such a statement is often that faith is
belief without evidence. Therefore, since there’s no scientific evidence for
the divine, we should not believe in God. But that statement itself ― that
evidence is necessary ― holds a further hidden premise that all
evidence worth examining has to be scientific evidence. And beneath that
assumption, there’s the deeper worldview ― it’s a kind of dogma ― that
science is the only reliable way to truth. But that itself is a faith
statement. It’s a deep faith commitment because there’s no way you can set
up a series of scientific experiments to prove that science is the only
reliable guide to truth. It’s a creed.
John Haught; The Atheist
Delusion; Salon; Dec. 2007